Numbers 19-20a
29 Oct 2026 - Theology
The Red Heifer
This chapter contains the law of the red heifer, which was judged by Jewish sages to be the most incomprehensible in the Torah. It became a classic example of a “statute”, often understood as a law that has no reason, or at least none that we can understand. Other statutes include laws like the prohibition of sowing mixed seeds together (Leviticus 19:19), wearing cloth of mixed wool and linen (Leviticus 19:19), and eating milk and meat together (from Exodus 23:19 and Exodus 34:26). Commands of these kind were given to us by God, but they may not have obvious human benefits.
What is really odd is: What is the law doing here?
Surely this law belongs elsewhere. It is about a ritual of purification for one who had come into contact with the dead and now sought to enter the Tabernacle. It’s place in the text should be in the book of Leviticus, which deals with purification rituals (see Leviticus 12 to Leviticus 16). It does not obviously belong in the book of Numbers, which deals with the second half of the Israelites’ journey through the wilderness.
We have just read about a serious revolt (or revolts) against the leadership of Moses and Aaron. What does this have to do with a law of purification? Let’s look at the text.
Numbers 19
The Lord tells Moses and Aaron what must be done when someone becomes unclean by touching or coming too close to a corpse, a human bone, or a grave. This happened often in ancient Israel. Since family and friends cared for the dying and the dead, most Israelites at one time had to touch, move, or bury a corpse. Yet they believed that contact with death made them unclean again. The Lord commands the ritual of the red heifer for this purpose.
A heifer is a young cow, one that has never given birth. The Lord instructs the Israelites to bring an “unblemished red heifer in which there is no defect” to Eleazar the priest. The red heifer must be sacrificed outside of the camp, with Eleazar watching. Eleazar must then dip his finger in the cow’s blood and sprinkle the blood seven times in the direction of the Tent of Meeting. The dead heifer must be burned - adding cedar wood, hyssop, and scarlet material (probably red yarn) to the fire. Eleazar and the person who helped him must then wash their clothes, bathe their bodies, and return to the camp. Because they were near the red heifer, they were unclean until evening. (2-8)
Someone else who was clean had to gather the ashes of the heifer and put them in a clean place outside of the camp. By touching the ashes, this person also became unclean until evening. To finish the preparations, the ashes of the heifer had to be mixed with fresh water. This mixture of water and ashes was considered to be purification from sin, and would remove impurity. (9-10)
The Lord commands: “The one who touches the body of any person will be unclean for seven days” (11). The water and ashes mixture for purification must be sprinkled on the unclean person on the third day and on the seventh day. Even the person who does the sprinkling becomes unclean until evening and has to bathe.
Why did touching the ashes or coming near the red heifer make a person unclean, while sprinkling the ashes on an unclean person would make that person clean? Why was this sacrifice done outside the camp or not on the altar of the Tabernacle? Why does the priest sprinkle blood seven times toward the Tent of Meeting? Why should this sacrifice be a heifer, and not a bull? Why is the color red important - the red skin of the cow, the blood, and the scarlet red yarn? These are just a few of the questions that have puzzled scholars and biblical commentators.
Biblical law is not merely a set of rules whose only logic is that they are the will of God. The Law is rooted in history and cosmology. It reflects something other and larger than the law itself. Law is a way of putting right what we know, from history, to have been wrong. That is why the Torah includes both history (narrative) and law. God wants us to understand not only what to do, but also why. He wants us not just to obey, but also to reflect on and internalise the lessons of history.
Modern Bible scholars can help answer some of our questions. Thanks to their work, we know that in Mesopotamia, long before the time of Moses, magician-priests used this kind of ritual. The Israelite priests “adopted” these rituals, changing them slightly by taking out some of the “magic”.
The sacrifice was done outside the camp, away from the Tabernacle, with a cow and not a bull - all of which shows that it was not a normal Israelite sacrifice. The red things (the cow’s skin, the cedar wood, the blood, and the scarlet red yarn) all stood to represent blood. Blood was the stuff of life - losing it was bad, and being touched with blood that had been dedicated to God was good (good blood was used to ordain priests in Exodus 29):
Exodus 29:20-21 (NASB) - “And you shall slaughter the ram, and take some of its blood and put it on the lobe of Aaron’s right ear and on the lobes of his sons’ right ears, and on the thumbs of their right hands, and on the big toes of their right feet, and sprinkle the rest of the blood around on the altar. Then you shall take some of the blood that is on the altar and some of the anointing oil, and sprinkle it on Aaron and on his garments, and on his sons and on his sons’ garments with him; so he and his garments shall be consecrated, as well as his sons and his sons’ garments with him.”
The cedar wood and hyssop gave off a pleasing aroma when they were burned, like the incense used in the Tabernacle.
Numbers 20
Something extraordinary happens between Numbers 18 and Numbers 19. It is not stated explicitly in the text and takes us a while to realize that it happened: almost 40 years have passed. In Numbers 18 we read the final stages of the Korah revolt, in the second year of the journey, and now suddenly we are near the end. Without warning, the text leaps forward 38 years. There is nothing in the text to signal the leap in time, but the characters have aged. Almost an entire generation has died.
We see the first sign of the passage of time in Numbers 20:
Numbers 20:1 (NASB) - “…and the people stayed at Kadesh. Now Miriam died there and was buried there.”
Miriam was the one who set the story of the Exodus in motion as she watched over baby Moses floating in a basket down the Nile. Just as she was there in the beginning of the story, so her death marks the end of the story of that generation.
The reason Numbers 20 is preceded by the law of the red heifer is because the entire purpose of the ritual is to purify those who have come into contact with death.
The symbolism of the red heifer is simple. The red heifer itself represents life in its most primal form:
- it is an animal - an animal lives without consciousness of death
- it is red - symbolizing blood, which represents life itself
- it is an animal “on which a yoke has never been mounted” (2) - its life has never been constrained by being domesticated or used
The red heifer is killed, burned, and reduced to ash in a dramatic representation of death. The ashes are then mixed with those of burnt cedar wood, hyssop, and scarlet red yarn. This is part of the purification ritual of the metzora or “leper” in Leviticus 14.
They are then disolved in “living water” to be sprinkled over the person who has been contaiminated by contact with, or proximity to, a human corpse.
The phrase “living water” is an explicit metaphor. Water is the source of all life (plant, animal, and human). In the desert, you feel this with a peculiar vividness. Hence it became the symbol of God, who is life. God is to us as water is to the desert.
Jeremiah 7:13 (NASB) - “Lord, the hope of Israel, All who abandon You will be put to shame. Those who turn away on earth will be written down, Because they have forsaken the fountain of living water, that is the Lord.”
Psalm 63:1 (NASB) - “God, You are my God; I shall be watching for You; My soul thirsts for You, my flesh yearns for You, In a dry and exhausted land where there is no water.”
Immediately after we read about the death of Miriam in verse 1, we come to verse 2:
Numbers 20:2 (NASB) - “There was no water for the congregation, and they assembled against Moses and Aaron.”
We now understand the symbolic significance of the fact that when Miriam died, the flow of water to the Israelites ceased. As long as she was alive, there was water, i.e. life.
We die, but life goes on - that is the symbolic statement of the red heifer ritual. All that lives eventually turns to dust and ash, but life continues to flow like a never-ending stream. There is death, but there is also continuity. The dead live on in us, as we will live on in our children and in those whose lives we touch. As dust dissolves in living water, so death dissolves in the stream of life itself.
Before we are exposed to the death of Miriam, and later Aaron and Moses, the text provides us with profound metaphysical comfort. They died, but what they lived for did not die. We are not always privileged to complete the task, but others will take it on and move a little closer to fulfilment, just as the next generation of Israelites will take up the task of entering the land God had promised to them through their parents.
The red heifer ritual comforts us for the loss of Miriam, and for the existence of death itself. The touch of God, like the sprinkled drops of the waters of purification, heals our loss and brings us back to life.
References
- Spiros Zodhiates (Editor), The Hebrew - Greek Key Study Bible: King James Version (2008)
- Rabbi Seymour Rossel, The Torah Portion-by-Portion (2007)
- Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation - Numbers: The Wilderness Years (2017)